One day I was on the bus with my SLMB, where I was going is irrelevant but if it makes you feel better, I forgot. While on the bus, a few stops later, a lady with her daughter got on. Her daughter was cute as a button, with extra large curls, dressed all in pink, with a matching little purse. As the mother boarded and reached in her bag for her metro card so did her daughter. There were others who also wanted to board the bus so the mother grabbed her daughter and sat down after paying her fare.
While scene is itself is normal, even I went through that when my lil one was around three. I think, children enjoy going through all the same motions that adults do, though it can be a bit frustrating when out in public, since they feel the need to complete whatever task at hand regardless of the circumstances. That was not the issue with the mother and the daughter, the issue started once the bus started moving.
For the sake of this story I’ll give the mother and daughter names. The mother will be Amanda and the daughter we’ll just call her Suzie, to help make them easy to relate to. The song and dance that was about to happen is one that I seen before, but it’s the first time my SLMB got a front row seat.
As Amanda try to settle down with Suzie, (taking Public Transportation with a toddler and carriage can be a big ordeal), Suzie continued to rummage through her little purse until she finally fished out her metro card. Suzie held up her metro card like a winning lotto ticket, and Suzie was about to claim her winnings. Suzie decide that she knew exactly what to do with her metro card and felt she needed no assistance. Suzie did the toddler turn-a-round and slide on your stomach to get off her seat (if you have kids you know that move), which Amanda promptly sat her back. Little adorable Suzie was not happy, and she would let the entire bus know it also. As Suzie began to cry, Amanda did what so many other parents including myself have done. Amanda try to give Suzie a toy which promptly ended up on the floor. With the toy on the floor Suzie began to cry even louder, with screams of “NO” and “I WANT GO”, Amanda began going down the list. First the toy, then the quiet talk, yeah the one where parents whisper saying look you don’t want people to see you being bad, she tried a snack, even sat Suzie on her lap. As Amanda continued down the list Suzie would kick and scream louder and even began to fight back. All the while, my son would keep glancing back and fourth between Suzie and me of all people. My response was to my son was just to shrug my shoulders. Amanda and Suzie battled for about ten minutes. Suzie wore Amanda down, forcing her to walk her over while the bus was moving, so that she could use her metro card.
First, I am no professional when it comes to parenting nor am I a psychologist, but I blame Amanda for Suzie behavior. Like I said this is not the first time I’ve seen this same episode, I’ve seen it too many times, yet it always ends that same, with the parent tapping out saying “UNCLE”.
As parents we see our children as babies incapable of properly communicating with us, and not knowing any better. News flash: They know, it is the parent who doesn’t understand the child, and they are communicating with us before they even say a word. How is that so you may ask well it’s simple our first response to others is from what we see. If some one approaches you with a smile your more likely to smile back, why, it’s you communicating with that person without speaking. How bout this, if you happen to bump into some one who does not share your language tell them the saddest story you have with a smile. They will not know what you’re saying, but they will smile back, and vice versa. So Amanda by whispering to Suzie with a gentle smile, is giving her the wrong message. This is a rather small thing to correct with children, though many parents think they have to yell and have the meanest face to show that they are not happy, this type of parent is also wrong. Amanda just needs to speak sternly with a facial expression to match.
The biggest issue with Amanda and Suzie is that Amanda has shown Suzie it takes some time to get what see wants. Children like adults live by routines. Suzie knows if she continues to cry she will get what she wants, and Amanda has taught her that. If Suzie has never gotten what she want from kicking and screaming what purpose would she have to do it then. Amanda has given that behavior a purpose. For Amanda to change that she would have to not give in once she has said NO. Once Suzie realizes that NO means she will not get it, she will find other ways of getting it, which hopefully are more constructive. There are ways to get rid of unwanted behaviors, but first parents need to be aware of what they are really teaching their children.
I have shared this story with several of the parents that I follow on twitter below you will read their perspective on the same situation.
@nycitymama

Well, a couple of things here. Saying no, for the sake of no is wrong. I believe Amanda is sending mixes messages here. She let’s Suzie walk around with a little purse, she even has her own metro card to feel like “a big girl”, yet when Suzie wants to act like a big girl, Amanda let’s the stress of the moment take over and denies her the experience.
What Amanda needs to do is make sure Suzie has her metro card ready, like a big girl, or just take it away all together.
I’m not sure I’m the best for giving parental advice, especially when dealing with tantrums, but I am learning that rules with no reason or understanding, are as if there were no rules at all. Even though they are small children they deserve to understand the reason of things.
I recently wrote about a program I discovered to improve communication between my children and myself. I hope that Amanda took the time to talk to Suzie about the bus incident. We will never know. But allowing her to swipe the card would have avoided the whole mess for sure.
Carol Cain
Founder, Publisher
The Adventures of a NYCity Mama
www.nycitymama.com
Managing Editor
NY Metropolista
www.nymetropolista.com
@kidlution
The scenario you describe is a classic. Only there is a slight twist. Tantrums can be ignited when a child’s wants/needs/desires are thwarted. Parents may have to thwart their kid’s desires for very good reasons, such as a toddler trying to cross a road, a kid wanting to eat cookies before dinner, a kid wanting to stay up past his bedtime.
Other times, a child’s wants/needs/desires may be thwarted not because what she wants is dangerous, inappropriate or unacceptable, but, because it is inconvenient for the parent. Such is the case you describe.
This child clearly had very goal-oriented behavior (getting her Metro card out of her mini-purse) and was attempting to imitate the behavior of her main role-model, her mother. I think that the thwarting of that goal is what led to this outburst. This child was not going to stop until she got what she wanted, or her mother made it clear that it was a non-negotiable issue. Clearly, we see who won out.
The kid was in tantrum mode and the mom likely was experiencing a flood of emotions herself (embarrassment, irritation, anger) and may have given-in to the child for a variety of reasons that we can’t even begin to guess at. Maybe she thought, “I have to get this kid to be quiet so as not to disturb the other passengers. I have tried every trick in the book. I’m going to give in so I can keep the peace for the sake of my bus mates.”
Either way, you are right in your thoughts that the mom has just reinforced for the daughter that she only needs to tantrum a little louder, a little longer to get what she wants. The fireworks might get bigger the next time.
Fortunately, this is one of those situations in which the problem could have been avoided altogether. When we as parents recognize and accept the fact that life just “takes longer” when we have little ones in tow, we can slow down just a little to let kids do the things that they need to learn how to do. This was a missed opportunity for the child to get a sense of satisfaction over having located her Metro card and swiped it across the meter….”just like mama did.” While it may have taken 1-2 more minutes from the outset, it would have saved time in the long run.
Fortunately for parents, just like kids, we have the opportunity to do it different next time, if the way we just did it didn’t work out so well. For some, the learning curve is much bigger than others.
Read more about
“How to Tame a Tantrum”
Wendy Young, LMSW, BCD, is a mom of 3 school-aged children and a Child & Family Therapist in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula. She consults to numerous early childhood programs, including Head Start and Early Head Start. She is the founder of
“Kidlutions: Solutions for Kids” and the creator of the “Spin-Doctor Parenting Blog”. She is passionate about helping parents deal with challenging, difficult and intense children.
@jaimami

As a first time mom, I can say that I don’t think anyone can prepare you what being “mami” means. As soon as my son learned how to walk and talk (and talk back!) I was just floored. Hate if you want to but I plan my outings around my child’s schedule. Why? To avoid an incident like that lady on the bus. Because I just don’t have time for it. Here’s my secret to minimizing tantrums in public. And yes he has trained me well!
If your child still naps…plan your outing after naptime. Bring their favorite toy with them to occupy their time. I have always taken my son out to stores even as an infant and he’s always done very well for this reason. Plus he’s naturally curious, always has been, so he entertains himself by checking out his surroundings. Also, he brings what he calls his “jet pack” which is a backpack full of his favorite toys of the moment, sometimes his blankie and snacks. Snacks are always good to keep cranky children well behaved.
Master “the speech”. This is what I tell him in the car before we enter a store. He’s not even three yet and knows it by heart. Here goes: mami: are you going to behave? Booba: yes Mami: are you going to sit in the cart? Booba: yes. Mami: Are you going to listen? Booba: yes, I will be patient. And yes, he says the word patient!
So my two cents…Suzie needed a nap! But the way I see it, Amanda should have just avoided all the drama by letting Suzie swipe her card too. She could have prepared by going on the bus last, or giving her some sort of “the speech” prior to getting on the bus. Trust me people, it works!
Janice “Jai” Correa
www.Mamistimeout.com
Parents tell me how would you deal with Amanda? Do you agree with points stated by myself and guest speakers?
Copyright secured by Digiprove © 2010 Matthew Ciscart
Continue reading
children, family, feelings, life lessons, Parenting